Today’s Pies

We start out each morning with each of these flavors available, but quantities are limited so flavors and sizes do sell out each day.  Please see our order policy below:

For Pick Up Today: 

Please call the pie shop and we’ll reserve your pie(s) from today’s inventory. Pre payment is not required for same day reservations.

For Pick Up Tomorrow: 

Tomorrow’s pies are currently in process. Please call tomorrow morning and we’ll reserve your pie(s) from tomorrow’s inventory. Pre payment is not required for same day reservations.

For Pick Up After Tomorrow

We take Pre-Orders for future dates (after tomorrow) on our web site (see Order Online) and over the phone in our shop. Pre-Payment via credit card is required for pre-orders. 

Call Now To Reserve a pie for today!

(845)535-3290

To place an order for a future date:

In The Freezer Case

In addition to the fresh pies listed above, we also offer frozen Quiche and Key Lime in our 7″ size (serves 4-6). They are fully baked and come with serving instructions. It’s always good to have one of these in your freezer at home just in case.  

Quiche