Every morning we start with these pies on hand, but quantities are limited and some flavors sell-out throughout the day. If you are coming in today for a specific pie, in a specific size it’s a good idea to call ahead and reserve it.
To place an order for pick-up at a future date please call the pie shop. 48 Hours notice is required for orders.
Our Crispy all-butter cookies are made from scratch right here in our shop and are available individually and by the box (shown above).
Flavors: Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Raisin, Snickerdoodle & Shortbread
Every morning we are baking fresh muffins from scratch. The flavors change with the season just like our pies, but some we make year round like Blueberry muffins and Corn muffins.
We have our full muffin selection ready by 8am and they are usually sold out by about noon. As with the pies you can always call ahead to reserve what you want.
Do you have anything savory? Yes we do! We are now offering a spinach and feta cheese quiche with red peppers. We bake these every morning sell them by the slice now. We are planning to have whole quiches available for purchase soon…
Coffee & Espresso
Coffee with you pie? We’ve got the most delicious, freshly roasted coffee and espresso beans from Coffee Labs Roasters in Tarrytown NY! We love being able to see our beans being roasted and carrying our orders back to the pie shop in burlap sacks!
Ice Cream & Milkshakes
A la mode? Yes of course, but you can’t just have any old ice cream with this pie. We proudly serve Jane’s Ice Cream which is hand made here in Hudson Valley.
We carry 8 delicious flavors that you can enjoy in a cup, on a sugar cone or atop a slice of pie! If you’d like to take some home with your pie we also carry Jane’s Ice Cream by the pint in a few select flavors.
Flavors by the scoop: Vanilla Bean, Killer Chocolate, Strawberry, Cappuccino Kahlua Calypso(Coffee), Mint Chip, Coconut Almond Joy, Cookies ‘n Cream, Kitchen Sink.
Make it a shake! Milkshakes can be made with any of our 8 flavors with our homemade whipped cream on top.
Flavors by the pint:Vanilla Bean, Killer Chocolate, Cappuccino Kahlua Calypso(Coffee) & Coconut Almond Joy.