Pie Shop

pi lady shop inside

If you’re in the mood for pie you have come to the right place! At our Pie Shop in Nyack we offer a large variety of whole pies, of course, but we also have much more..

Whole Pies

We start out each morning with these flavors available at this time of year. Quantities of each size and flavor are somewhat limited and flavors do sell out throughout the day. If you want to make sure the pie you want is available give us a call and reserve it. 

Pie By The Slice

pie slices

Every day we have a selection of about 8 of our pies available by the slice. Just pick a flavor, have us warm it up, and decide if you’ll have have it a la mode, with whipped cream, or both! 

Ice Cream

If you do decide to have ice cream on your pie, you’re in for a treat! We proudly serve Jane’s Ice Cream which is made right here in the Hudson Valley. We also use Jane’s ice cream in our milkshakes and ice cream sandwiches.  

Coffee & Espresso

Whether you’re stopping in on your way to work or grabbing a late afternoon pick- me-up, we offer a full selection of coffee and espresso based drinks. We get all of our coffee from Coffee Labs’ Roasters in Tarrytown, NY. 


Every morning we bake fresh muffins from scratch. Made with whole wheat and white flour they are not too sweet and make great morning treat. Boxes of (6) are also available and make great gifts for family, friends & clients. The muffin selection changes daily and is usually 4 to 6 flavors.  We don’t take advanced orders for our muffins, but you can call in the morning and reserve them. 


The Pie Lady is also a big fan of cookies! We make crispy, all-butter cookies in 4 flavor: Chocolate Chip, Oatmeal Raisin, Snickderdoodle & Shortbread. Our cookies are sold individually and by the box. They are also the “bread” in our ice cream sandwiches. Oh and yes we have milk by the glass! 

Pie Shop Details

  • Open 7 Days a week.

  • Indoor Seating for 18

  • Parking Lot Next Door

  • Free Wifi

  • 2 Bathrooms

  • Kids Love It Here!

  • Mom's & Dad's Too!

  • Located on Main St. in Nyack

  • Between Broadway and Franklin St.

  • 2 Minutes from Tappan Zee Bridge

Map & Address