“American Homemade” since 1996. Our pie shop in Upper Nyack, New York carries on the same homemade baking tradition that my mom started in 1996. Selling homemade pies and baked goods from the back porch of our house in the village of Nyack. A sign on the corner telephone pole led customers directly to our door, and little by little Mom became known as the “Pie Lady of Nyack.” Read More »
This board indicates the pies we are currently baking and the sizes that are available. The blue spaces indicate sizes that we don’t bake. Our menu changes with the seasons so check back from time to time.
Our Pie Shop in Nyack is open 7 days a week and is located on Rt. 9W just north of Nyack Hospital. We have a parking lot and inside seating.
Is Nyack a little too far out of the way for you? Don’t worry, we sell our pies at a number of farmers markets in Westchester County, NY and Brooklyn, NY on a weekly basis. Click the link below and find the market nearest to you.
What People Are Saying
“…Where homemade looks and tastes are not pie in the sky.”
— The New York Times
“This place is one of a kind. It’s a wonderful little shop.
When you walk in you can smell the uniqueness and
hard work put into these pies. ”
— Yelp Reviewer Naim
(Visit our page on Yelp)
— Trip Advisor Reviewer Margaret
(Visit our page on Trip Advisor)